Date: Fri, 22 Nov 2002 19:19:29 -0500
From: Chris Pinkenburg <pinkenburg@bnl.gov>
Reply-To: e895-l@bnl.gov
To: "e895-l@bnl.gov" <e895-l@bnl.gov>
Subject: Pion Paper

Hi Jenn,
Thank you for extending the deadline. It's a really nice piece of work
and from my point of view perfectly good to go.

I would leave the 0-5% out of the title and in fig 2 the number of
particles under the gaussians and the number of entries don't add up. As
far as I recall PAW includes all under- and overflows in the entries
which is probably not what you want to compare your numbers to.

One thing in fig13 and fig14 (which need y-axis labels) strikes me as
being peculiar: only pi+ seem to have a last collision with Kaons or
pions. Is that correct? Shouldn't the probability go only up to 1 or
what does relative probability = 10 mean?

I guess my affiliation should be 2,7.

Cheers
Chris